The Delhi High Court has today directed shadow library website Sci-Hub and LibGen to not “upload and make available” any new article infringing copyright of the global publishers Elsevier Ltd., Wiley India Pvt. Ltd. and American Chemical Society.
A single-judge bench of Justice Rajiv Shakdher while hearing the petition through video conferencing further asked for an affidavit mentioning the details of the defendant Alexandra Elbakyan including her address.
The petition has been filed by 3 top-tier global publishing houses, Elsevier Ltd., Wiley India Pvt. Ltd., American Chemical Society publishing journals, books, research work, etc in the field of scientific and academic publications alleging that the Sci-Hub and Libgen are infringing copyright and provide free access to paid research work on their repositories.
Senior Advocate Amit Sibal appearing for the petitioners submitted, “The applicants are global publishing houses, publishing science academic publications, wherein, we receive draft publications and then we peer-review it and publish it. Our business model is some free journals and majorly subscription-based …we are here before this Court for the subscription-based publications.”
“The defendants are related or we can say mirror and pirate websites…now they collect donations in millions buy paywalled publications and uploads copy on LibGen as well as on Sci-Hub…PayPal has disabled their payment system but they come up with new ones…” Sibal added.
Advocate Nilesh Jain appearing for Alexandra submitted that we have received the copy of the petition last night and would need at least 2 weeks time to respond.
Mr Sibal said, “there is no defence, they have published the articles, it may be directed that I’ll give an entire list of publications which they have uploaded and they take it down and it stays down till next date.”
Whereas, Justice Shakdher asked Sibal, “Where were your client for so many years? These sites are known by everyone.
However, the bench has directed the defendants that “no-new article will be published ‘uploaded or make available’ infringing the copyright of the petitioners, file Written Statements, reply, on or before December 31.
Also Read: Delhi HC questions need for building gazebo in Nizamuddin West park
The bench have listed the matter for further hearing on January 6.
Comments are closed.