International Criminal Court: Role and Work

INTRODUCTION

The establishment of International Criminal Court stemmed from a treaty of Rome Statute. The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court was ratified by 10 nations On 11 April 2002.  The Rome Statute was a United Nations (UN) treaty. The ICC is headquartered at The Hague within the Netherlands.

The primary goal behind the establishment of the International Criminal Court (ICC) was that it will be handled as an International court of last resort. Canada was one of the earliest advocates of this historic tribunal. The Rome Statute officially came into force on the 1^st of July 2002 after greater than 60 countries ratified this treaty. This Statute laid down the significant aspects of the ICC like basic founding rules, jurisdiction, position of the court docket; fundamental functioning and so on will be discussed in this article. Presently, governors have ratified the legal obligations under ICC.

There are just a few criticisms that the ICC has been dealing with. More so United States of America formally renounced its legal obligations to the International Criminal Court in Might 2002 proper after it signed the statute in April 2002. Many different Nations have expressed their reservations relating to the precise utility of the ICC and its effectiveness. To understand the present conflicting opinions you will need to understand the actual role and the functioning of the ICC.

Functioning of the ICC

Read Also: COVID-19 and its Impact on Education System in India

The ICC has 4 organs-

1. Presidency or the Head of the Court
2. Chambers- Ensuring fair trials
3. Office of the Prosecutor- Conducting investigations and prosecutions
4. Registry Supporting the Court

Presidency or the Head of the Court

The Presidency consists of 3judges (1 President and 2 Vice-Presidents) elected by an absolute majority of the 18 judges of the Court.

Learn additionally:

Max term– 2-3 years

Role- Administration of Court except for the Office of Prosecutor. It also ensures the enforcement of sentences.

The Chambers

The Court has 3 judicial divisions Pre-trial, Trial & The Appeals composed of seven, six and 5 judges respectively. The 18 judges, President and the Vice- President are assigned to those chambers.

The Office of Prosecutor

That is an independent body of the Court. It mandates, receives and analyses data on conditions of worldwide crimes throughout the jurisdiction of the ICC. It ultimately conducts an investigation on such cases. It comprises of three divisions

1. The Investigation Division- conducts an investigation
2. The Prosecution division
3. The jurisdiction, Complementarity and cooperation division

The Registry

Main role- assists the court to conduct fair and impartial public trials. It provides Administration and operation support to the ICC.

The Operational processes

1. Referrals

Any State can request the Office of Prosecutor to carry out Investigation on a certain case within the jurisdiction. Even if a selected state is not a celebration to the Rome Statute, it might nonetheless request the help if the ICC in sure circumstances. The UN Security Council can also refer circumstances to the ICC. The Prosecutor himself can take initiatives and launch an investigation in case of bonafide data. That is the method of referrals.

2. Evaluation

The Prosecutor analyses the situation referred and determines whether the case is within the jurisdiction or not. He also determines the kind of case i.e the 4 principal classes mentioned above earlier than allowing it for investigation. Lastly he notifies the related State Events in regards to the Court docket intention to provoke investigation.

3. Investigation

The Workplace of Prosecutor initiates an investigation and permits the collection of evidence. The chance concerned for the safety of the victims and witnesses is of main concern. The State events additionally help in such investigations.

Arrests

1. Only the Pre-Trial Chamber can request the Prosecution to issue a warrant after the correct investigation has been carried out. Even summons are sent after the Pre- Trial chamber permits it.
2. A warrant for arrest might solely be issued for the explanation of acquiring the looks of the accused and likewise to stop the particular person from persevering with crimes.
3. After warrant is issued the Registrar transmits requests for Cooperation from state events.
4. As soon as the required accused is arrested the ICC is informed.
5. The ICC doesn’t have any specific power arrest suspects and thus relies on the Cooperation of State Parties.
6. Responsibility to execute warrants issued is on State Parties. ICC is just the Judicial pillar and doesn’t have its own police force. The States form the operational pillar.
7. The ICC has a detention centre which is in conformity to the international human rights.

Observe- if the Suspects or accused don’t have a way to pay for legal assistance the Court assigns one for them.

Prices earlier than Trial

1. The suspects seem in Court docket and as soon as the fees are confirmed within the Pre-trial listening to, The prosecution’s presence is essential.
2. After the Pretrial the Court docket has 3 choices both to substantiate the fees and commit the case or to adjourn the listening to and order the prosecution to give you adequate proof, or decline the fees.
3. As soon as prices are confirmed the Trial Chamber takes up duty. All procedural points are thought of first earlier than the Trial begins.

The Trial

1. The Trial Chamber asks the accused whether or not he pleads responsible or not.
2. If the accused admits guilt then the Trial Chamber makes positive that the accused understands absolutely the results of his admission.
3. Then it convicts the accused. If he doesn’t admit to his guilt then the trial proceeds and the prosecution tries to show his case. Materials proof and witnesses are offered. The burden of proof is on the prosecution. the accused has the fitting to look at the prosecution witnesses.

The Judgment and sentencing

1. After listening to the victims and witnesses and on evaluation of the proof produced earlier than the court docket the choose determines whether or not the accused is responsible or not.
2. The choose might award a jail sentence or a fantastic or forfeiture of the proceeds of belongings. The ICC can not give dying penalty. The utmost sentence it might award is 30 years. The ICC can award life sentences in uncommon circumstances.
3. The convicted are required to serve their sentence in a selected State designated by the Court docket. The imprisonment is ruled by the respective State legal guidelines.

Observe- Appeals are allowed. The prosecution might enchantment in opposition to procedural errors, convictions and acquittals. The convicted stays in custody throughout pending appeals.

CONCLUSION

The ICC is fairly practical and the procedures are coherent with many of the nationwide jurisdictions. Most significantly it serves an amazing position in regulating the Worldwide Legal Justice system but there are just a few Criticisms.

The Rome Statute is a multilateral treaty which is totally different from the ad hoc international tribunals. Neither the victors nor the Security Council resolution created it.

ROLE AND FUNCTIONING

The Rome statute contains 128 Articles and encompasses both Substantive and Procedural laws for Criminal resolution. The Statute is an instrument of International Criminal law. This criminal law instrument is additionally supplemented by Parts of Crime[i], Guidelines of Procedure & Proof[ii] and Codification. These are the required requirement of the precept of legality and the requirements of a good trial with a purpose to defend the accused from procedural harassments[iii].

Read Also: Under Domestic Violence Act Can Divorced Wife Claim Right To Residence?

Purpose

1. The basic define of Article 1 and the Preamble of the Rome Statute pronounces its main purpose. The ICC is meant to follow the Principle of Complementarity. This principle lays down the relationship between the National Criminal Justice systems of the state parties and the ICC.  In fact, the Preamble states that serious crimes should go unpunished and shall not solely be paid heed to at a national level but also should be enhanced via international cooperation.
2. ICC has jurisdiction over persons involved with critical crimes which attract international concern. When against the law dedicated is actually in opposition to humanity at the giant (Eg- Conflict crimes) then such crimes are below the purview of the ICC. Crimes that are much less severe in nature can simply be handled inside Nationwide jurisdictions.
3. The National courts will be able to exercise jurisdiction over a broader category of crimes. The nationwide courts will be able to deal with international crimes lesser in-depth and fall under the brink of the ambit of ICC.
4. Article 4 of the Statute lays down two inherent wants of ICC

1. International Legal Personality
2. The legal capability was necessary for the train of its features and the success of its functions.

Role of ICC

1. The ICC enforces a built-in mechanism for bringing about Individual Accountability for International Crimes.

The main role of ICC is to adjudicate upon particular person accused of War crimes, Crimes against humanity and Genocides.  For the previous few a long time nations have felt the necessity of a correct mechanism that implement legal guidelines that can maintain people accountable for severe International crimes. For example- in case of violations of the Geneva Conference, Genocide conventions, customary laws for crimes etc; national courts were expected to resolve the matter. This created confusion as to which national jurisdiction should be referred to. and additionally, its noticed that in most cases the Nationwide Courts have been reluctant to behave on such circumstances owing to widespread systematic violence and most significantly because of the involvement of States themselves.

Read Also: Relationship between Civil Law and International Commercial Law

Governments themselves have been concerned in such crimes thus national courts couldn’t successfully resolve such crimes. Thus, the perpetrators remained protected from impunity. Thus, to punish the brokers of such governments and convey about not solely collective but also individual prison legal responsibility for such crimes, the ICC was established.

Note- the ICC doesn’t have universal jurisdiction. It only has jurisdiction over States which have voluntarily signed under it i.e. the States which have consented to their jurisdiction.

2.  To enforce a International justice System to prevent impunity.

As discussed above since the national courts have been unwilling to act upon cases involving international genocide, war crimes etc; there was a dire want for a built-in third-social party or an International Justice System. ICC fulfills this want.

Read Also: All you need to know about Crime Against Women Under Indian Penal Code,1860.

3. To resolve the limitations of the Ad Hoc tribunals

As evident from historical past (like the problems of former Yugoslavia and Rwanda and even Nazi Germany) advert hoc tribunals was once set as much as remedy worldwide crimes and convey about conviction. Nonetheless, the scope of such tribunals have been restricted and thus the ICC steps in, with a purpose to overcome such limitations.

4. The ICC recognizes the position of the Safety Council.

The Safety Council has a particular position to keep up peace and safety. It’s talked about below the Rome Statute that the Safety Council will probably be referring circumstances to ICC in order that unnecessarily unfastened Advert Hoc tribunals will not be created.

5. The ICC offers with 4 kinds of Worldwide Crimes.

1. Genocide- people having the intent to destroy incomplete or a part of a nationwide, ethnic, racial, or non-secular group
2. Conflict crimes- severe breach of the Geneva Conference. This conference lays down prohibitions on torture and assaults on civilians.
3. Crimes in opposition to humanity- gross violations with regard to large-scale assaults in opposition to civilian populations. It additionally contains homicide, rape, torture imprisonment, bondage and slavery.
4. Crimes of aggression- the risk of armed pressure by a state against one other state. Also covers State actions violative of the UN Constitution.

Functioning of the ICC

Read Also: How the school and college education change after National Education Policy 2020

The ICC has 4 organs-

1. Presidency or the Head of the Court
2. Chambers- Ensuring fair trials
3. Office of the Prosecutor- Conducting investigations and prosecutions
4. Registry Supporting the Court

Presidency or the Head of the Court

The Presidency consists of 3judges (1 President and 2 Vice-Presidents) elected by an absolute majority of the 18 judges of the Court.

Read Also: How To Become An Entrepreneur In India Need to Know

Max term– 2-3 years

Role- Administration of Court except for the Office of Prosecutor. It also ensures the enforcement of sentences.

The Chambers

The Court has 3 judicial divisions Pre-trial, Trial & The Appeals composed of seven, six and 5 judges respectively. The 18 judges, President and the Vice- President are assigned to those chambers.

The Office of Prosecutor

That is an independent body of the Court. It mandates, receives and analyses data on conditions of worldwide crimes throughout the jurisdiction of the ICC. It ultimately conducts an investigation on such cases. It comprises of three divisions

1. The Investigation Division- conducts an investigation
2. The Prosecution division
3. The jurisdiction, Complementarity and cooperation division

The Registry

Main role- assists the court to conduct fair and impartial public trials. It provides Administration and operation support to the ICC.

The Operational processes

1. Referrals

Any State can request the Office of Prosecutor to carry out Investigation on a certain case within the jurisdiction. Even if a selected state is not a celebration to the Rome Statute, it might nonetheless request the help if the ICC in sure circumstances. The UN Security Council can also refer circumstances to the ICC. The Prosecutor himself can take initiatives and launch an investigation in case of bonafide data. That is the method of referrals.

2. Evaluation

The Prosecutor analyses the situation referred and determines whether the case is within the jurisdiction or not. He also determines the kind of case i.e the 4 principal classes mentioned above earlier than allowing it for investigation. Lastly he notifies the related State Events in regards to the Court docket intention to provoke investigation.

3. Investigation

The Workplace of Prosecutor initiates an investigation and permits the collection of evidence. The chance concerned for the safety of the victims and witnesses is of main concern. The State events additionally help in such investigations.

Arrests

1. Only the Pre-Trial Chamber can request the Prosecution to issue a warrant after the correct investigation has been carried out. Even summons are sent after the Pre- Trial chamber permits it.
2. A warrant for arrest might solely be issued for the explanation of acquiring the looks of the accused and likewise to stop the particular person from persevering with crimes.
3. After warrant is issued the Registrar transmits requests for Cooperation from state events.
4. As soon as the required accused is arrested the ICC is informed.
5. The ICC doesn’t have any specific power arrest suspects and thus relies on the Cooperation of State Parties.
6. Responsibility to execute warrants issued is on State Parties. ICC is just the Judicial pillar and doesn’t have its own police force. The States form the operational pillar.
7. The ICC has a detention centre which is in conformity to the international human rights.

Observe- if the Suspects or accused don’t have a way to pay for legal assistance the Court assigns one for them.

Prices earlier than Trial

1. The suspects seem in Court docket and as soon as the fees are confirmed within the Pre-trial listening to, The prosecution’s presence is essential.
2. After the Pretrial the Court docket has 3 choices both to substantiate the fees and commit the case or to adjourn the listening to and order the prosecution to give you adequate proof, or decline the fees.
3. As soon as prices are confirmed the Trial Chamber takes up duty. All procedural points are thought of first earlier than the Trial begins.

The Trial

1. The Trial Chamber asks the accused whether or not he pleads responsible or not.
2. If the accused admits guilt then the Trial Chamber makes positive that the accused understands absolutely the results of his admission.
3. Then it convicts the accused. If he doesn’t admit to his guilt then the trial proceeds and the prosecution tries to show his case. Materials proof and witnesses are offered. The burden of proof is on the prosecution. the accused has the fitting to look at the prosecution witnesses.

The Judgment and sentencing

1. After listening to the victims and witnesses and on evaluation of the proof produced earlier than the court docket the choose determines whether or not the accused is responsible or not.
2. The choose might award a jail sentence or a fantastic or forfeiture of the proceeds of belongings. The ICC can not give dying penalty. The utmost sentence it might award is 30 years. The ICC can award life sentences in uncommon circumstances.
3. The convicted are required to serve their sentence in a selected State designated by the Court docket. The imprisonment is ruled by the respective State legal guidelines.

Observe- Appeals are allowed. The prosecution might enchantment in opposition to procedural errors, convictions and acquittals. The convicted stays in custody throughout pending appeals.

CONCLUSION

The ICC is fairly practical and the procedures are coherent with many of the nationwide jurisdictions. Most significantly it serves an amazing position in regulating the Worldwide Legal Justice system but there are just a few Criticisms.