Above: The latest spate of deaths at BRD Hospital was reported on August 27, 28 and 29, 2017 Photo: UNI
With the state government silent, can the courts take suo motu action, is the question
As many as 61 children—mostly newborns and infants— have been reported dead at Gorakhpur’s Baba Raghav Das (BRD) Hospital in just the last 72 hours. This is the same medical facility—the biggest in Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath’s pocket borough which receives patients from 36 eastern UP districts, Bihar and Nepal—where over 30 children had suffocated to death on August 10 and 11 due to disruption in the hospital’s oxygen supply.
The latest spate of deaths was reported on August 27, 28 and 29. Although the hospital is yet to officially declare the number of deaths and what caused them, local media reports claim that 11 children had died at the hospital’s encephalitis ward while 25 each had been reported dead from the neo-natal intensive care unit (NNICU) and the general paediatric ward.
The Adityanath government, which is already facing criticism for a total of 70 shocking deaths of children at the hospital three weeks ago due to disruption of oxygen supply, has chosen to stay mum on these deaths reported over the past three days. Chief Minister Adityanath and his health minister Sidharth Nath Singh, who are usually very vocal on social media platforms like Twitter, have not uttered a word on the latest tragedy, let alone offer any remedial measures.
This, even as local doctors claimed that the death toll could rise further over the next few days.
After the first spate of deaths, the government had reacted hastily with the arrest of former principal Dr Rajeev Mishra and his wife Dr Purnima Shukla by the UP Special Task force. They were arrested from Kanpur. At this point, though, the administration has neither any political nor legal hiding zone. There are voices which say that with the government completely apathetic to the situation, the issue is now ripe for the high court to take suo motu action.
Unofficially, the hospital authorities have been telling media persons that the current spate of deaths has been caused due to encephalitis, health complexities in newborns, pneumonia, sepsis, etc. According to a Hindustan Times report, the hospital has seen a substantial increase in patients suffering from encephalitis, water-borne and vector-borne diseases over the past few weeks which has led to overcrowding.
A doctor at the encephalitis ward of the BRD hospital told local television news channels that the situation is set to get worse in the coming days as eastern Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Nepal—the key areas from which patients pour in at the facility—“are still receiving heavy rainfall and are reeling under the effects of floods which has a direct correlation with the spread of encephalitis.” Due to the overcrowding, the doctor said: “we have been forced to accommodate as many as four patients on a single bed in the paediatric ward and the condition at other wards is similar”.
According to hospital records, this year till Monday at least 1,250 patients have died in the encephalitis and neonatal wards.
A ground report of the appalling situation at the BRD hospital that was published in a leading national daily on Wednesday quoted Dr RN Singh, a paediatrician, who has worked extensively in UP on encephalitis cases, saying: “Insufficient homework was done to control the outspread of Acute Encephalitis Syndrome… measures like fogging to kill mosquitoes, de-silting of water bodies, vaccination and chlorination of water were not done in time.”
A recent central panel probe into the mortality situation at the BRD hospital had found a severe shortage of medical staff in the neonatal and paediatric wards along with major lapses in maintaining basic hygiene standards. The inquiry had also revealed that only three of the over 30 nurses in the facility were trained to handle newborns.
When the earlier deaths of children were reported from the hospital on August 10 and 11 due to disruption in oxygen supply that was caused after the hospital management failed to settle a bill of Rs 60 lakh made out by the oxygen supply agency, the Adityanath government had claimed that the children had died due to encephalitis and other medical reasons. While it rejected the widely accepted theory that lack of oxygen had led to the deaths, the government did increase the number of doctors and paramedical staff at the hospital.
—India Legal Bureau